News

Search News






The Community Buzz

What is this?

Should I tell my husband I helped our 15-year-old daughter have an abortion




One woman's story of whether she should be loyal to her husband and reveal her daughter's abortion or keep her daughter's secret as she originally promised her.

Read Full Story: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-1166227/...

Shared by



Comments (13)

Add Comment
Comments Options
Sort comments by:




mariposa_mami
mariposa...

Female, 35, San Juan, PR

Posted Apr 01


From the article:



I have never wanted to confess anything to my husband as much as I longed to tell him the truth. But I just couldn't bring myself to say it. How could I now tell him that his 15-year-old daughter had just had an abortion - and that I, her mother, had helped her to arrange it? I wondered if he would ever forgive me for the lies and deceit I've been responsible for.

In the weeks since then, Chloe has continued to struggle with anxiety and depression as a result of the termination. Her schoolwork is suffering, too.

Our GP is trying to avoid putting her on any kind of medication and hoping that time, and the counselling she is still receiving at the clinic, will help her to recover.

Richard is very aware that there's something wrong - but he simply doesn't know what it is.

I feel terrible about Chloe, about the termination, and about lying to my husband. Even though I was only trying to do the best for everyone, I seem to have made an incredibly painful mess of everything.

I think it's inevitable that the truth will come out at some stage, and I'm dreading what my husband will say about my part in all this.

I just wish I'd been honest with him from the beginning. But it's too late for that now.


Byakuugan_Mod
Byakuuga...

Male, Age Private, New York, NY

Posted Apr 01


The secret can destroy the family faster than the actual act. There is no way the counseling can be effective if they continue to keep the shame and secrecy of the decision that was made. She will continue to be fearful of her father finding out.

It isn't even the wife's secret to keep. She should convince her daughter to tell the father what has happened if she truly wants to help her daughter. I don't have much advice on how she can patch things up with her husband though.

By agreeing to keep the secret she has reinforced the child's fears about her father. He is clueless and helpless about the situation and that will soon cause a whole mess of new issues to deal with.


mariposa_mami
mariposa...

Female, 35, San Juan, PR

Posted Apr 01


i am torn on this one because as a mother myself, i sense the mother's unconditional love kept her from sharing with her husband. however as a wife, i know that there cannot be a strong and healthy marriage if there are secrets lurking in the darkness.

how would i feel if my daughter went to my hubby and shared an experience like this with him and not me? hurt and angry.

when do you know as a parent the right time to keep your child's confidence? are there circumstances where "mother's know best" and " what he (father) does not know, won't hurt him"...

i know if he happens to read this article and can come to the conclusion that it is about his family, there will be hell to pay in that family........

i just dont see a postive outcome in this situation.


mariposa_mami
mariposa...

Female, 35, San Juan, PR

Posted Apr 01


I am also wondering if the mother is reinforcing in her daughter's mind that she has done something so despicable and filthy by not confiding in her father.

it's like saying, " honey, i understand what you did and why you did it but your father will never understand or forgive you'

either way, i feel that she (the mother) has somehow contributed to the notion that her father is inept and incapable of dealing with difficult situations.


maddox2u2
maddox2u2

Female, Age Private, Schererville, IN

Posted Apr 01


The mother has condoned an atrocious act of MURDER.
If she's feeling pain - GOOD. However, living in fear
is stupid. She should talk with her daughter and they
should both confess the evil act they did to the husband/father.
They should also reveal to him the suffering they have both
been going through by keeping it a secret. I find it strange
that they don't feel bad about the murder itself; they only
have guilt feelings about keeping it a secret from the
father.


YourOUTLANDER
YourOUTL...

Female, 47, Coleman, FL

Posted Apr 02


I'm curious as to what type of man this woman is married to where nyther she nor her daughter are comfortable enough to bring alll things to the table. This is a family. Every family has it's secrets BUT they are not supposed to exclude family members. Was this preganacy the father's business? of course it was.... it was completely unfair to inform the would be grandfather that the would be grandmother and mommy to be teamed together and kilt his grandbaby... on purpose.

Teen pregnancy may be epidemic but it certainly is not the end of the world. This is where FAMILY comes in. We babysit or arrange daycare. Sure everybody's life must be rearranged to make room for the new family member but it can be done.

But these two women...ONE OF WHOM IS A GROWN AZZ WOMAN AND POTENTIAL GRANDMOTHER... made secret plans to murder the newest member of the family to make their lives easier and increase the chances of a bright future....with blood on thier hands via the murder of the innocent. heartbreaking

I feel that the wife, the daughter, together should have included the husband/father. But it is easy to see that a wall has already been set in place as pointed out by the wife/mother re the father's weak communication skills... though i suspect that is an excuse to try to justify the wife not confiding in the husband.
As a wife/mother who is and has been knowing her husband, believe it or not, it is part of her duties to bring her family together... not rip it apart... that means that she IS TO BRIDGE the gap... a mediator if you will. Instead, she simply added another brick to the wall.... trust is the issue... she was supposed to lead her daughter to feel the trust that daughters should have toward their fathers... I CAN TELL MY DADDY (AND MAMA) ANYTHING AND EVERYTHING IN BETWEEN...b/c i know regardless of the situation, mine WILL be there for me... and i for them.... the mother taught her daughter to keep secrets from daddy... not wise atall... leave daddy out the loop? wow... that's like saying you effed up and daddy can't handle it and won't love you anymore .. ok dysfunctional.... the whole family needs counseling and i don't feel like allllllllllllllll that typing


YourOUTLANDER
YourOUTL...

Female, 47, Coleman, FL

Posted Apr 02


typo: ....it was completely unfair to not inform the would be ....


mariposa_mami
mariposa...

Female, 35, San Juan, PR

Posted Apr 02


Good morning everyone! Thank you Byak, maddox, volup., taxfree and yourOutlander for your insightful and wise comments.

the consensus seems to be that we all feel that the father has a right to have been included in the decision making and the mother must make it a priority to talk to him and confess what occurred.


MeOwnPerson
MeOwnPerson

Female, Age Private, Pomona, CA

Posted Apr 02


The wife/mother should have said something as soon as the daughter was pregnant. She should have gotten her daughter to talk to her father.

Since that didn't happen, she needs to get her daughter to open up to her father about her pregnancy and abortion, then the mother needs to come clean about her participation. If she can't the daughter to open up, get the husband to talk to his daughter and let her know that no matter what he is there for her.

It sounds like the daughter cares a lot about what her daddy thinks of her and doesn't want to ruin her daddy's girl relationship with him. I know it was hard to tell my parents about my pregnancy because I loved and respected them so much and thought be pregnant would make me a big disappointment to them.

I don't know the family, but this secret should not make or break them as long as the wife can get some dialouge between father and daughter.


MeOwnPerson
MeOwnPerson

Female, Age Private, Pomona, CA

Posted Apr 02


Also, I told my mother first about being pregnant because she's female and would understand me better as mother. Its was like telling your mother you got your first period before you told your dad. Anywas, my mother didn't tell my dad. She allowed me to break the news


PirateHooker
PirateHo...

Female, 28, Glendale, AZ

Posted Apr 03


I think it is the mothers responsibility to call a family meeting. To let the father kno whats going on and 2 also get the minor on birth control. Because its painfully obvious she's not thinking about her actions. And she's still young. This should have been discussed as a family. Because its a family issue.


BeautifullyHuman_
Beautifu...

Female, Age Private, Los Angeles, CA

Posted Apr 03


Should you tell your husband you assisted your daughter in going to get an abortion.......well that depends on what kind of husband you have. If your husband is abusive- then absolutely not!

However, if he is not abusive and supportive...yes! Actually you should have told when you first found out she was pregnant. That was a family concern and he has the right as you did to know.

Just my thoughts


mariposa_mami
mariposa...

Female, 35, San Juan, PR

Posted Apr 03


thank you for the comments MeOwnPerson, Pirate and Beautiful....

We can only hope that the mother and daughter have the strength to talk to the husband/father and begin the healing process for this family before it is too late....






The Prudential Insurance Company of America

Apply

Business Analyst

Category:

Information Technology

Region:

PA - Philadelphia


Liberty Mutual Agency Markets

Apply

Senior Claims Attorney

Category:

Legal

Region:

NH - Southern


The Scotts Company

Apply

Plant Supervisor - Medway, ME

Category:

Manufacturing and Production

Region:

ME - Northern/Bangor


Kforce Professional Staffing

Apply

Inside Sales Representative

Category:

Accounting/Auditing

Region:

TX - Austin